Plot Device
12
A character tries anal sex but finds out they don't like it.
Many people are willing to try new things in the bedroom, and when you try new things you either like them or you don't. In this situation, a character is willing to try anal sex and allow their partner to play with their ass. The character may either be enthusiastic about trying anal, quietly willing, or nervous but wanting to try. This can involve the partner using their tongue on the character's ass by licking the anus or penetrating the anus, it can involve the partner using their fingers to rub the character's anus, or finger the character's anus, or it can also involve the partner penetrating the character with a toy like a butt plug, a vibratory, a dildo, or a strap on, or if the partner has a penis they can penetrate the character's ass with the cock. The character consents to whichever act or acts their partner carries out. However, the character may find it feels weird, strange, uncomfortable or embarrassing. Describe emotions that are mostly negative. If the character's ass is licked or eaten they may feel embarrassed or ashamed that they are doing taking part in a filthy act, or may worry their partner will view them differently afterwards. If their ass is fingered, there will be an uncomfortable burn to begin with as the finger stretches the anus, then it may feel uncomfortable to have the finger inside of them. When the finger or fingers begin pumping it may just feel weird or invasive, with no pleasurable sensation. If the character has a toy or plug inserted, they may feel embarrassed and uncomfortably full, even though their partner finds it erotic. If the character is fucked with a strap-on or a cock, they don't orgasm. They can feel the lube in their ass, hear the wet noises as they are penetrated repeatedly. It may feel uncomfortable to be filled like that, or it may hurt a little to have their rectal muscles stretched so much. They also feel guilty as their partner clearly enjoys fucking their ass, but the character knows they won't do it again after this. Once the anal sex is over, the character will feel achy, loose, and the lube is uncomfortable on their skin. There is also feelings of shame and embarrassment for doing anal sex in the first place, and they regret it. They also feel conflicted because they had been willing to try it when they began.
RedQuill
RedQuill is a free AI erotic story writer that lets you instantly explore and remix your kinky, sexy fantasies in a safe and vibrant community.
Innerworlds, Inc.
169 Madison Ave, STE 11408
New York, NY 10016
© 2025 RedQuill. All Rights Reserved
Story Generators
Story Categories